Gas vs Electric vs Charcoal BBQ: Which Should You Buy in the UK?
Three BBQs. Three very different Saturdays. One is about flavour, one is about speed, and one is about fitting into a small space.
The 10-second answer Flat or balcony? Go electric. Garden, and you BBQ weekly? Go gas. Purist, or you want to take it camping? Go charcoal.
The comparison
| Charcoal | Gas | Electric | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Example | Weber Go-Anywhere | Weber Spirit II E-310 GBS | Ninja Woodfire OG701UK |
| Price seen | From about £101 | Typically £549–£649 | About £229–£300 |
| Cooking area | 42 × 26cm | Three burners, big grill | 28 × 37cm |
| Start-up | 15–20 minutes to light and get ready | Instant | Instant |
| Flavour | Most traditional smoky taste | Good, with Weber’s Flavorizer Bars | Smoky via wood pellets, lighter |
| Needs | Charcoal, firelighters | Gas bottle | Outdoor power socket |
| Portable? | Yes, no power needed | Not really, heavy | Only near a socket |
| Balcony? | Check your lease | Check your lease | Listed as safe, still check your lease |
Prices are what I found at the time of writing and change often. Amazon availability and dispatch for the Go-Anywhere varies, so check that it ships from Amazon UK or a UK-based seller.
Charcoal: maximum flavour, maximum effort
Charcoal gives the most traditional smoky flavour, and the Weber Go-Anywhere is a good, cheap example: a 42 × 26cm grill with folding legs for camping, picnics and small gardens.
The catch: you have to light it, wait, manage the vents, then let it cool and dispose of the ash. Rainy weekday evening? Not ideal.
Safety: never use a charcoal BBQ indoors, in a tent or in a garage. It gives off carbon monoxide.
Gas: the weeknight winner
The Weber Spirit II E-310 GBS represents the category well: instant ignition, burner-by-burner heat control and a 10-year warranty listed by UK retailers. Gas is the easiest option for regular use. Light it, wait a few minutes, cook.
The catch: it costs far more than the other two, it’s heavy (about 52kg), and gas doesn’t give you true charcoal flavour.
Read our full Weber Spirit II E-310 GBS review.
Electric: the small-space hero
The Ninja Woodfire OG701UK is an electric grill with a smoker box that burns real wood pellets for flavour. It’s listed as safe for balconies and small patios, which makes it the easiest to fit into a flat, and it also air-fries and bakes.
The catch: it needs a power socket and a small plate (28 × 37cm) limits big parties.
60-second decision guide
- Live in a flat with a balcony? Electric. Check your lease first.
- Have a garden and BBQ every week? Gas.
- Love the taste and the ritual? Charcoal.
- Going camping or to the park? Charcoal. It’s the only one that needs no power.
- On a tight budget? Charcoal is the cheapest to start with. Fuel costs add up, though.
- Cooking for 8 or more regularly? Gas, for the bigger cooking area.
Check before you buy
- Read your lease or building rules before buying anything with flames or hot coals, especially in a flat.
- Gas grills need a bottle and the right regulator. Confirm before you order.
- Electric grills need a safe outdoor power source. Use an outdoor-rated socket or lead and keep connections dry.
- Measure your space. The Spirit II E-310 GBS is listed at about 132cm wide.
Quick FAQ
Which gives the most authentic flavour? Charcoal, most people agree. Gas with flavour bars and electric with wood pellets narrow the gap, but don’t match it.
Can I use a gas or charcoal BBQ on a UK balcony? Many leases and building rules restrict open flames. Check yours before you buy.
Which is the most convenient for weeknights? Gas and electric both start instantly. Gas has the bigger cooking area; electric adds air frying and smoking.
Ready to decide? Weber Go-Anywhere → · Weber Spirit II E-310 GBS → · Ninja Woodfire OG701UK →


















